New York City, we need your take on this one — because the City Council is coming for the lobster pot.
On Thursday, November 19, 2026, Councilmen Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan introduced a bill — Introduction 1188-2026 — that would prohibit every food-service establishment in New York City from boiling live lobsters, crabs and other crustaceans. The bill has been referred to the Council’s Committee on Health.
What the Bill Would Do
Under the proposal, dropping a live lobster or crab into boiling water would be off the table at every restaurant in the five boroughs. A first violation gets a warning. After that, it’s a $100 fine per animal — and in a busy seafood kitchen, that math adds up fast.
Lobster would NOT disappear from New York menus. Restaurants could still serve lobster and crab — the animal would just have to be killed by another method before it hits the pot. Councilman Feliz made that point himself:
“I also want to be clear: this bill does not remove lobster from the menu or prevent anyone from eating it.”
The sponsors point to scientific studies suggesting crustaceans feel pain. And New York wouldn’t be going first: similar bans on boiling crustaceans alive are already on the books in Switzerland, New Zealand, England, Austria, Norway and parts of Australia.
The Other Side: Restaurant Owners Are Steaming Mad
Plenty of New York restaurant owners are not trying to hear any of it. They say boiling is how lobster has been cooked for generations, and they see the bill as the city reaching straight into their kitchens. Restaurateur Angelo Vivolo did not hold back:
“This is nuts… It’s idiocy. This regulation is absolutely insane.”
Photos: Mayor Zohran Mamdani via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0); lobster photo by Derek Keats via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Where the Bill Stands Right Now
Let’s be clear about the status: this is a proposal only. It has NOT passed, and no vote is scheduled. If it ever did become law, it would take effect 180 days after signing — so no, nobody is raiding a lobster tank tonight.
New York has been here before, too. The city’s 2019 foie gras ban ended up tangled in court appeals for years. And this isn’t the only animal proposal floating around City Hall — a separate one would ban giving out live goldfish as prizes.
Here’s the post that got everybody talking:
HOW DO YOU FEEL ABOUT IT?
So now it’s your turn, FreddyO family. Is this protecting animals that can feel pain — or is this the city doing way too much and messing with people’s food and livelihoods? Seafood lovers, restaurant owners, animal lovers — we want to hear from YOU in the comments. Drop your take below and let’s talk about it. 🦞
























Leave a Reply